Frontline Plus vs. Advantage – Which One is Better?
Frontline Plus and Advantage are two of the the most oldest flea treatments for dogs and cats. Hence, it is obvious that there is a constant battle amongst pet owners when it comes to shopping for these flea preventive products. Although these two products have been categorised under the same group there are distinct points that makes them different from each other.
Let us look at some of these pointers given below:
Advantage for dogs and cats kills approximately 98% fleas within half a day of administration and chewing lice within a week’s time of administration in both dogs and cats. It prevents fleas from nipping the pet within three to five minutes of administration. It is effective against flea larvae and adult fleas and even treats Flea Allergy Dermatitis (FAD). But it is not effective against ticks. While Frontline Plus for dogs kills 100% fleas within a day or two of administration and is even effective against chewing lice and ticks. It kills all life stages of fleas. It is effective against fleas and brown dog ticks for a maximum of 30 days and paralysis ticks for a maximum of 2 weeks. While Frontline Plus for cats is effective against fleas, flea larvae and chewing lice, but is not effective against ticks.
SO, THE IMPORTANT TAKE AWAY POINT OF DIFFERENTIATION AND SIMILARITY BETWEEN BOTH THE PRODUCTS IN TERMS OF EFFICACY IS THAT ADVANTAGE FOR DOGS & CATS IS EFFECTIVE IN ELIMINATING ADULT FLEAS, FLEA LARVAE AND CHEWING LICE FOR A MAXIMUM OF 30 DAYS. WHILE FRONTLINE PLUS FOR DOGS IS EFFECTIVE AGAINST ADULT FLEAS AND ITS ENTIRE LIFE CYCLE ALONG WITH CHEWING LICE AND BROWN DOG TICKS FOR MAXIMUM ONE MONTH. FRONTLINE PUS FOR CATS HAS THE SAME EFFECTIVENESS AS FRONTLINE PLUS FOR DOGS EXCEPT THAT IT DOES NOT WORK IN ELIMINATING TICKS. SO, IF YOU ARE CONCERNED ABOUT TICKS ON YOUR FURRY PAL THEN FRONTLINE PLUS IS THE BEST OPTION. WHILE IF ADULT FLEAS, FLEA LARVAE AND CHEWING LICE IS YOU CONCERN THEN YOU CAN OPT FOR ADVANTAGE.
Advantage contains Imidacloprid which is a neonicotinoid chemical which acts on adult fleas and lice in the same way as nicotine does which causes excessive stimulation which leads to paralysis and death of these parasites. While Frontline Plus contains Fipronil and (S)-Methoprene. Fipronil is an insecticide that has an adverse effect on the nervous system of fleas and ticks. While (S)-Methoprene is an insect growth regulator (IGR) that prohibits the maturation of flea eggs and larvae. When both these ingredients are combined it results in total destruction of adult fleas, flea life cycle, larvae and ticks in dogs. Although Frontline Plus for cats has the same ingredients as dogs it is not effective against fleas.
SO, ADVANTAGE CONTAINS ONLY ONE INGREDIENT – IMIDACLOPRID WHILE FRONTLINE PLUS CONTAINS TWO INGREDIENTS – FIPRONIL AND (S)-METHOPRENE.
Types & Dosage
Both the products’ dosage is based on the pet’s weight. Advantage for dogs is available in the pack size of 1, 4, 6 & 12 with different colour codes:
For small dogs up to 4 kg – Green
For medium dogs 4 – 10 kg – Aqua
For large dogs – 10 – 25 kg – Red
For extra large dogs – Over 25 kg – Blue
For cats and kittens the pack size remains the same but with different colour codes:
For kittens & small cats up to 4 kg – Orange
For cats Over 4 kg – Purple
Frontline Plus for dogs is available in 3, 6 and 12 pipettes with different colour codes:
For small dogs up to 10 kg – Orange
For medium dogs 10 to 20 kg – Blue
For large dogs 20 to 40 kg – Purple
For extra large dogs 40 to 60 kg – Red
Frontline Plus for cats comes is also available in 3, 6 and 12 pipettes.
SELECT THE BEST PACK SIZE OF EITHER OF THE PRODUCTS BASED ON THE WEIGHT OF YOUR PET FOR BEST EFFECTS.
Pricing for both the products is comparable and is contingent on the weight of the pet, the quantity of the product and the merchant from whom you purchase the product. A pack of 6 applicators of Advantage for dogs with 2 free doses up to 4 kg at VetSupply will cost you $ 63.19 while a pack of 6 applicators of Advantage for cats with 2 free doses at VetSupply would cost you $ 68.13. If you opt for a pack of 6 applicators of Frontline Plus for dogs with 2 Doses Free up to 10 kg at VetSupply it will cost you $ 37.99 and the pack of 6 applicators of Frontline Plus for Cats with 1 Dose Free will cost $ 59.99.
SO, SELECT THE APPROPRIATE PACK SIZE CONSIDERING THE PRICING OF BOTH THE PRODUCTS.
On paper, Frontline Plus is the clear winner between the two products. But a closer look would make you feel that Advantage is more effective against fleas. If you are concerned about fleas and ticks then Frontline Plus for Dogs is the product, but if you are looking for protection against only fleas Advantage would work best. It all depends on the situation. So, do what suits your furry pal.